Representative clients

Acadia Insurance Company

Admiral Insurance Company

Allianz Insurance Group

American Family Insurance Group

Auto-Owners Insurance Company

Berkley Mid-Atlantic Group

Capital Insurance Group

Cincinnati Insurance Company

Crum & Forster Insurance Company

Donegal Insurance Group

Erie Insurance Group

Farm Bureau Insurance

Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Company of Marble, PA

First American Property Casualty Insurance Company

FM Global Group

General Casualty Insurance Companies

Harleysville Insurance Company

Highlands Insurance Group, Inc., In Receivership

J&J Snack Foods

Liberty Mutual Insurance Companies

Liberty Regional Agency Markets

Lititz Mutual Insurance Company

Lloyd's of London

Markel

Mercury Insurance Group

Metropolitan Property & Casualty Insurance Company

Motors Insurance Company

Nationwide Group

Penn Millers Insurance Company

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Safeco Insurance Companies

Seabright Insurance

Secura Insurance Companies

Selective Insurance Company of America

Sentry Insurance Company

State Auto Insurance Companies

Travelers Companies, Inc.

USAA Group

Westfield Group

Windsor-Mount Joy Mutual Insurance Company



Best's Recommended Insurance Attorney 2011



Proud Sponsor National Association of Subrogation Professionals

Major Property Subrogation

Operating from strategic locations around the country, the Law Offices of Robert A. Stutman, P.C., is organized around the recovery of major insurance losses wherever they occur. The firm has represented more than 60 different insurance companies on substantial property losses throughout the United States. Over the last 15 years, the firm has handled thousands of property subrogation cases, has brought claims against almost every major product manufacturer in the country and has tried hundreds of property subrogation cases. We were named liaison counsel for over twenty insurance companies in an apartment fire class action suit and have litigated a $60 million fire in which we sued an entire industry under a “concert-of-action” theory. With sixteen attorneys devoted exclusively to handling property subrogation matters, we are the largest subrogation-only firm in the country. Return to top …

Workers' Compensation Insurance

For many carriers, recovery of Worker's Compensation insurance claims through subrogation is often overlooked. Unlike many of the recovery models in use today, the Stutman model for Worker's Comp recovery relies on early intervention and investigation, with a cutting-edge focus on large losses based on the category of worker injury, all designed to maximize recoveries.

The Stutman model centers on an immediate, knowledgeable and thorough investigation of all major workers compensation claims. Our attorneys lead an investigation that includes, where appropriate, preservation of the scene, retention of experts, interviewing witnesses and securing critical evidence. The investigation remains focused at all time on the identification of potentially responsible third parties.

Our team has investigated countless large losses in areas which include: construction accidents, accidents involving products, motor vehicle accidents, including vehicle crashworthiness, industrial accidents and roadway defect cases. Return to top …

Mass Tort Litigation

Most insurers pay claims on small losses that are not cost-effective to litigate through subrogation. When these are the result of the failure of products with a common defect, Stutman's Mass Tort Unit can affect recovery by grouping thousands of similar claims into a mass tort action. Additionally, major fire, explosion and water losses that cause damage to multiple insureds are handled efficiently through one investigation and mass tort action. The Stutman team has handled numerous such mega-losses including Wildfire actions as well as countless apartment complex losses on behalf of numerous insurance companies.

Over the past 10 years, the firm has developed a reputation as the recognized leader in efficiently and economically pursuing mass tort litigation. We have recovered millions of dollars for insurers through mass tort actions involving defective washing machine hoses, toilet tank fill valves and supply lines, and other products with common defects.  The firm has identified numerous trends for products that fail repetitively in a similar manner. Some examples include certain brands of dryers, bathroom exhaust fans, metal halide lights and CSST flex lines just to name a few. Return to top …